Is Soy Protein Isolate Bad For You

The Truth About Soy Isoflavones

Soy Protein: Good or Bad?

One reason why most guys avoid soy is its high content of isoflavones, a class of phytoestrogens. These compounds have weak estrogen-like effects.

Soybeans are the primary food source of isoflavones. Other foods, such as peanuts, beans, and chickpeas, contain these polyphenols too, but in smaller amounts.

According to a study published in the Journal of the American Oil Chemists Society, soy protein isolate only retains 26% of the total isoflavones in soy flour. These natural compounds are lost during washing, extraction, and other processes.

What this means is that soy protein isolate is lower in isoflavones than soybeans and other soy products.

These naturally occurring compounds should not be equated with the hormone estrogen, states a 2016 review featured in Nutrients.

Unlike estrogen, they dont increase the levels of C-reactive protein, an inflammatory marker. Additionally, isoflavones dont affect the thyroid gland, breasts, or uterus, whereas excess estrogen does.

The Linus Pauling Institute says that soy isoflavones may improve blood lipids and vascular function, relieve menopause symptoms, and protect against some types of cancer. More studies are needed to confirm these findings.

They May Contain Added Sugar Calories Or Even Toxic Chemicals

Adding protein powder to a glass of milk or a smoothie may seem like a simple way to boost your health. After, all, protein is essential for building and maintaining muscle, bone strength, and numerous body functions. And many older adults don’t consume enough protein because of a reduced appetite.

But be careful: a scoop of chocolate or vanilla protein powder can harbor health risks. “I don’t recommend using protein powders except in a few instances, and only with supervision,” says registered dietitian Kathy McManus, director of the Department of Nutrition at Harvard-affiliated Brigham and Women’s Hospital.

Role In The Growth Of The Soybean Plant

Soy protein is generally regarded as stored protein held in discrete particles called “protein bodies” estimated to contain at least 60% to 70% of the total protein within the soybean seed. This protein is important to the growth of new soybean plants, and when the soybean seed germinates, the protein will be digested, and the released amino acids will be transported to locations of seedling growth. Legume proteins, such as soy and pulses, belong to the globulin family of seed storage proteins called legumin and vicilins , or in the case of soybeans, glycinin and beta-conglycinin. Grains contain a third type of storage protein called gluten or “prolamines”. Edestin, a legumin class reserve protein from hemp seeds have six identical subunits. There is one hexameric protein in the rhombohedral unit cell.

Soybeans also contain biologically active or metabolic proteins, such as enzymes, trypsin inhibitors, hemagglutinins, and cysteine proteases very similar to papain. The soy cotyledon storage proteins, important for human nutrition, can be extracted most efficiently by water, water plus dilute alkali , or aqueous solutions of sodium chloride from dehulled and defatted soybeans that have undergone only a minimal heat treatment so the protein is close to being native or undenatured. Soybeans are processed into three kinds of modern protein-rich products soy flour, soy concentrate, and soy isolate.

Don’t Miss: Protein Shake Cholesterol

Soy Contains Estrogenic Properties

Next, soy naturally contains properties known as isoflavones, , that actually mimic estrogen in the body once consumed. Though some studies show that this can actually be a good thing in some instances, such as in helping women have less hot flashes during menopause, other studies show that it can cause health problems. For instance, having extra estrogen could potentially result in hormone imbalances, infertility or disease.

Good For Pregnant Women

What is Soy Protein Isolate? Is it bad for you?

According to a study published in the Journal of Perinatal Education, soy protein is a good source of vitamin D. The study also says that fortified milk and fortified soymilk are the only trustworthy dietary sources of this vitamin, as other dairy products contain little to no vitamin D. So, for women who are sensitive to the sun or do not get as much sun as they like, soymilk serves as a great dietary supplement.

Recommended Reading: Special K Protein Cereal Healthy

Its Never One Sided Over 170 Negative Studies Might Suggest Otherwise

The story for and against soya is not one-sided and yes Ive cherry picked two studies above to illustrate negative aspects of soya. Many will argue a case for soya and others, like me, will argue the case against. The trouble is for me that even a handful of negative studies will worry me. The trouble is there are more than a few, here is a link to another interesting article with links to over 170 negative studies relating to soya consumption. With such a significant number of published studies even those fanatical about soya must have nagging doubts about consuming it in even moderate amounts.

Say No To Soy Protein Isolate

Now that youre a protein powder guru, you should have no problem picking an option that is best for you.

Soy protein isolate may be a super common choice of protein to buy, but it comes with a lot of downsides. Dont get caught up in convenience. There are better options!

Make plant-based protein your best friend! Unlike soy protein isolate, its all-natural and perfect for gaining muscle, losing weight, and maintaining a healthy diet. You get so many other benefits besides more protein as well.

If youre looking for the best plant-based protein out there, IdealRaw Protein is the way to go. IdealRaw made sure to give you all essential amino acids, a bunch of health-boosting superfoods, and a completely natural, artificial-free protein. It really is the best protein shake out there! So dont wait, get yourself some today!

Don’t Miss: Vega One Compared To Shakeology

Risks And Side Effects

Although soy foods may be associated with several potential health benefits, there are a few side effects and risks that need to be considered as well.

For starters, isoflavones act as phytoestrogens, meaning that they mimic the effects of estrogen in the body. For this reason, many people choose to avoid soy foods due to concerns about their effect on hormone-linked cancers, such as breast cancer.

Interestingly enough, however some studies have actually found that soy isoflavones could actually be linked to a lower risk of developing breast cancer. According to one 2016 review, higher consumption of soy products was linked to a 30 percent lower risk of developing breast cancer among Asian women.

Of course, its important to note that these populations typically consume non-GMO, fermented and minimally processed soy foods, which is a stark contrast to many of the highly processed products consumed in most western countries.

Because of the phytoestrogen effects of soybeans, many also wonder: Is soy bad for men? Studies have turned up mixed results on the impact of soy consumption on hormone levels for men.

Allergies to soy products are also very common, with one study estimating that soy allergy affects around 0.4 percent of children. Although many people do outgrow these allergies, its important to avoid soy products if you have an allergy to prevent adverse side effects.

Potential Health Risks Of Soy

soy bean benefits protein milk bad for you what is soy protein isolate side effects

Processed soy and cancer. Not all soy is created equally. Soy offers the most benefits in its purest form the soybean. Foods like edamame, tofu, and soy milk offer the most health benefits. Seeing soy as an ingredient on a label does not mean the food is healthy or that it offers the benefits of soybeans.

For example, soy proteins are often isolated from soybeans to make protein shake powder. This process changes the soy so that it is more likely to increase the insulin factor in your blood. Soy protein isolate may increase your risk for developing cancer.

Allergies. Some people are allergic to soy. Signs of a soy allergy include:

Get emergency help for any trouble breathing. If you experience any of these symptoms, remove soy from your diet and talk to your doctor about your concerns. You may grow out of your soy allergy over time, so try reintroducing it to your diet after several months or years have passed.

Thyroid medication. It is possible that soy can interfere with hormone-based thyroid medicines used to treat hypothyroidism. One study showed that people who consume more soy are at a greater risk for hypothyroidism. However, the same study also showed a decreased risk for insulin resistance, inflammation, and high blood pressure.

There are risks and benefits to including soy in your diet. Talk to your doctor about your risk factors and any medications you are on to see how much soy makes sense for you.

Don’t Miss: Protein Powder Like Shakeology

First Things First: What Is ‘soy Isolate Protein’

Hate to be the bearer of boring news here, but soy protein isolate is quite literally just that: protein that’s been isolated from soybeans via chemical engineering. In order to do this, the soybeans are first washed with an acid and then neutralized in an alkaline solution, says Michal Hertz, RD, a dietitian in New York City.

At the end of the entire SPI-making process, you’re left with a dry powder that’s about 90-95% protein and nearly carbohydrate- and fat-free, according to the Soyfoods Association of America. Because it’s such a protein powerhouse, this plant-based powder is typically used to enrich other packaged foods from protein bars to veggie burgers. Oh, and you can also blend it into smoothies.

Foodthe Truth About Almond Soy Rice And Flax: Decoding Dairy And Vegan Milks

A new study found that soy milk is a more nutritionally dense option than other milk alternatives due to its high protein and phytonutrient content. Soy milk may also be a good alternative for individuals who cant have milk but still want the calcium as some soy brands fortify with this important bone-building mineral. Look for soy milk options that have no added sugar or other additives and above all, make sure the source comes from whole soybeans, not from soy isolate.

Also Check: Can Low Protein Cause Headaches

Soya As A Source Of Protein For Sports Nutrition

Assuming you are not vegan, soya really has no place in sports nutrition, pea in our opinion is a better alternative. The biological value of soya is lower than the big three, those being whey, egg and micellar casein. Soya is lower in essential amino acids and contains few branched chain amino acids, so again its use is questionable at best. The following human study quite clearly demonstrates soyas inferior ability to stimulate protein synthesis vs milk proteins. The authors quoteMilk-based proteins promote muscle protein accretion to a greater extent than do soya-based proteins when consumed after resistance exercise The next study focuses on the effect of healthy males consuming 56 grams of soya protein daily for a month. Serum testosterone dropped by 19%, absolutely the last thing you want if you are an athlete. The authors quote Soya protein powder decreases serum testosterone levels in healthy men and acts as an ER- agonist.

Differences Between Soy Products

Soy protein isolate bad

Soy products contain varying amounts of protein. Foods that contain soy protein isolate, for example, have the highest amount of protein, followed by soy flour, whole soybeans and finally, tofu. This is important because the potential negative side effects of soy may be related to the level of proteins and isoflavones in soy. Foods that have added soy protein and isoflavones can react differently with the body than whole soy foods such as tofu, soy silk and miso, according to Penn State College of Agricultural Sciences. Foods with higher levels of isoflavones can potentially increase the risk of cancer.

Don’t Miss: Should I Drink Protein If I Want To Lose Weight

Frequently Asked Questions On Soy Protein Isolate

  • What is Soy Protein Isolate?

Soy Protein Isolate is a high-quality plant-based protein that is isolated from the soybean, by grinding soybean into a meal, which contains no hulls or fat. The soybean meal is then processed into Soy protein isolate, which consists of 90% protein. Soy Protein Isolate is high in protein and low in carbohydrates has emerged as one of the greatest alternatives to dairy protein. Similar to animal protein, Soy Protein provides our bodies with the full range of essential amino acids. AS-IT-IS Soy Protein Isolate is a highly refined and purified soy protein powder that offers 27g protein per serving. We use SUPRO, soy protein isolate from Solae, Dupont, USA, the world leader in soy nutrition.

  • What are the benefits of Soy Protein Isolate?
  • Is Soy Protein suitable for lactose-intolerant?

Yes, Soy Protein being a non-dairy protein, is the best suitable protein source suggested for those with lactose intolerance. The vegetarian and vegan-friendly protein offers a good amount of protein per serving, has a complete amino acid profile required for protein synthesis. Soy Protein is an excellent protein choice for people allergic to dairy-based products or those who follow a vegan diet.

  • Is Soy Protein easy to digest?
  • Is Soy Protein good for the heart?
  • What are the ways to consume Soy Protein supplements?
  • Which one to choose, Soy Protein or Pea Protein?
  • I am confused about which one to choose, Soy Protein or Whey Protein?

What Is Soy Milk

Though the processing of soy milk varies between manufacturers, the basic steps to make it are similar. The process involves mixing and blending soaked soybeans with water and draining the liquid into a milk form. It can easily be made at home, but many consumers take the more convenient move to purchase it at a store instead.

Don’t Miss: Nature’s Bounty Protein Shake Vs Shakeology

The Pros And Cons Of Soy Protein Isolate

No doubt, SPI is a super high-protein substance. And that’s exactly why vegetarians or vegans, and those allergic to cow’s milk, may use products with SPI, says Richards.

But unfortunately when it comes to SPI, it’s not as simple as: it’s high protein so it’s healthy. That’s because the process the soybeans go through in order to create the high-protein product is controversial.

“The extraction process often leaves behind residue from chemicals and metals like hexane or aluminum,” says Valdez. So if you consume SPI you’re likely noshing on at least some of these “leftovers”. While he says the amount of metal you’ll encounter from SPI is unlikely to be toxic, it’s generally considered good practice to limit the amount of metals in your diet where possible because in high levels they can be toxic. And things like gasoline fumes, quick-drying glue, spray adhesives, contact cement, arts and craft paints, and stain removers all expose us to these not-so-savory chemicals on a daily basis, according to Valdez.

“Another thing that adds to the SPI controversy is that they are genetically modified foods,” says Richards. This shouldn’t be surprising: at least 90 percent of the soybeans grown in the United States are genetically modified. So of course most SPI is, too!

Benefits Of Soy Free Plant

Soy Protein Isolate: The benefits of supplementing with Soy Protein

If youre looking for a clean, natural way to incorporate protein into your diet without turning to animal protein, soy free plant-based protein, like IdealRaw, is definitely the way to go.

As long as your protein powder gives you all nine amino acids, your post-workout drinks shouldnt have a problem helping you recover and build muscle.

Read Also: Do Special K Protein Bars Make You Gain Weight

Distinction Between Spi And Soy

Note that some organizations continue to state that soy is an unhealthy food and causes cancer. At best, this is a gross misunderstanding and confusion between actual soy and soy protein isolates. At worst, it is an attempt to smear the reputation of a truly beneficial food. We cannot help but notice that some groups that disparage soy are heavily funded by various aspects of the meat industry. As the old saying goes, follow the money to find the truth.

Soy protein isolates are quite different from soy foods. Soy consumed in less processed forms such as soy beans, tofu, tempeh, edamame or soymilk does not present the health risk that is present when consuming large amounts of highly processed soy protein isolates. Quite the opposite! Soy foods are very good sources of protein and other substances.

For more information on soy and the health benefits please see Is Soy Safe.

Is Soy Bad For You

Soybeans are one of the most controversial ingredients out there. In fact, it seems like nearly every week a new article is published promoting the dangers of soy, detailing the effects of soy on estrogen levels and hyping up the potential soy milk side effects in males.

Like most foods, there are both positive and negative aspects when it comes to soybeans, and some special considerations for those with specific health concerns. However, in moderation, many soy products can be enjoyed as part of a healthy diet.

Still, its best to select organic, fermented and minimally processed varieties and pair with a diverse range of other nutrient-dense foods to maximize the potential health benefits.

Don’t Miss: Protein Treatments For Natural Black Hair

Is Tvp Good Or Bad For You

TVP , similar to soy curls, seems like a great food for vegans at first.

But is it good or healthy for you?

Lets go over the main ways that TVP may or may not be good for you.

Nutrition is the starting point for whether a food is healthy or not.

Lots of vitamins and minerals? Probably healthy. Ton of sugar or trans fat? Probably unhealthy.

Here are the nutrition facts for a serving of 1/4 cup of TVP made by Bobs Red Mill:

  • Calories: 90
  • Iron: 10% RDA
  • Potassium 15% RDA
  • So its mostly just protein. In total, protein makes up 52 out of the 90 calories in a serving, or 58% of calorie, which is really useful for vegan athletes.

    In terms of vitamin and minerals, it has some, but nothing too crazy.

    TVPs nutrition profile is fine. If youre struggling to get enough protein, its a healthy addition to your diet. In terms of other nutrients, its not really very healthy or unhealthy.

    Popular Articles

    Related Articles