Do Protein Shakes Work For Weight Loss

How Does Protein Shake Supplements Work

Do Protein Meal Replacement Shakes For Weight Loss Work?

As defined by the Food and Drug Administration , dietary supplements contain items that contain a dietary element such as vitamins, minerals, amino acids, or herbs.

Protein shakes, commonly known as the building blocks of proteins, supply amino acids in this situation.

Dietary supplements are available in a variety of formats, including powders, pills, and liquids. While ready-to-drink protein shakes are available in liquid form, protein supplements are also available in powder form.

Powdered protein supplements are available in a variety of animal and plant-based forms.

Whey and casein, for example, are two of the most popular animal-based protein powders, both of which are often obtained from cow’s milk. If you have a milk allergy, however, egg white protein may be a better option.

You can choose from soy, pea, hemp, or rice protein as common plant-based proteins.

Finally, dietary supplements are supposed to assist you in completing or enhancing your diet, as their name implies.

Overall, protein shakes can be helpful when you do not have access to high-quality protein sources or cannot meet your daily protein requirements through food alone.

Now Lets Talk Carbohydrates

When we think of carbohydrates we often think of starchy sources such as bread and pasta which is why this necessary word receives a bad reputation in the realm of weight loss. However, carbohydrates are in fact in everything that we eat, our fruits and vegetables included. As an example, a cup of chopped fruit usually contains anywhere between 15-20 grams of carbohydrates. What is important to recognise is that not all sources of carbohydrates are made equal and that complex and wholesome sources can in fact support your weight loss journey.

As the backbone of many smoothie recipes, bananas form a staple in many fitness devotees diets. However, when it comes to shedding kilos or weight management, bananas receive a bad reputation. But contrary to popular belief, they can in fact aid in weight loss. Studies have found that bananas not only help reduce bloat and belly fat but they are also packed full of potassium which helps reduce water retention. Also a good source of fibre, a banana in your smoothie will help keep you feeling fuller for longer, cutting out the need to snack.

Oats are also a great way to add carbohydrates into your meal replacement smoothie with half a cup containing around 27 grams of carbohydrates. Oats are not only packed full of fibre and are low in calories, they are also a great source of protein and will help you feel full and satisfied after your smoothie.

Protein Shake Mistake #: Youve Got A One

Once youve invested in a massive tub of protein powder, its only good for shakes, right? Wrong. Constricting yourself to mixing it with milk or water alone means youre missing out on more muscle building and tasty alternatives.

The Fix

Add it to your meals to get the protein you need, as well as the nutrients. And the earlier, the better. Research from the University of Missouri-Columbia found adding a scoop to your breakfast porridge or cinnamon pancakes will make you less likely to overeat during the day.

Read Also: Where Can I Buy Premier Protein Clear

Meal Replacement Shakes Are Poor

When people limit the quantity of food they consume, the lesser food portions can make it quite challenging to meet the recommended daily nutrition intake requirements needed for good health.

Meal replacement shakes, however, are not found guilty of causing nutritional deficiencies in their consumers. This is because these shakes are fortified with minerals and vitamins that meet or even exceed a healthy individuals daily nutrient requirements.

What Makes A Good Protein Shake

Protein Shake for Weight Loss: How Does it Work?  Glam ...

For San Francisco-based personal trainer, massage therapist, and nutrition coach Jonathan Jordan, it all comes down to what is in your shake: many can be filled with additives and sugars, so he recommends making your own, and to reap the full benefits of the fruits and veggies you add by also adding a healthy dose of fat.

“Many of the key nutrients in fruits and veggies and other healthy foods are fat-soluble,” he says. “Without a little healthy fat to go along with them, you are literally, well, flushing them down the toilet instead of absorbing them.”

But whether you’re blitzing protein powder into a homemade smoothie or buying a ready-made shake off the shelf, there are a few things to keep in mind. You’ll want to consider opting for whey protein, which Ana Reisdorf, MS, RD, CDE, notes has been associated with increased weight loss, as compared to other protein sources.

Monica Auslander Moreno, MS, RD, LD/N, nutrition consultant for RSP Nutrition, agrees, calling whey protein “the gold standard” for muscle growth.

Jordan, too, opts for whey protein, noting that he mixes up a protein shake with BioChem Whey Vanilla every morning before work, while Moretti loves Garden of Life Certified Organic Grass Fed Whey Protein powder, which contains probiotics, too. Johnson also prefers whey protein, specifically F-Factor 20/20.

“The more fiber, the better the chances your protein shake will help you lose weight,” she says.

You May Like: Which Protein Powder Can You Buy With Food Stamps

How To Use Protein Shakes For Weight Loss

To help you lose weight, protein shakes should replace at least one meal a day, says Mir B. Ali, MD, Medical Director at MemorialCare Surgical Weight Loss Center at Orange Coast Medical Center.

For example, a 2021 review found that people lost more weight when they get 60% of their recommended calorie intake from meal replacements and 40% from other foods.

If you are using protein shakes for weight loss, it’s important you select a low-calorie one with no added sugar. Too much added sugar is linked to weight gain, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease.

How To Make A Protein Shake

While you can buy a protein shake at most health food stores, the best way to make a nutrient-rich protein shake is by creating your own at home, says Veltkamp. Here’s how:

  • Place one frozen banana into a blender with an teaspoon of cinnamon for a bit of flavor.
  • Then add ½ cup of plain, full-fat Greek yogurt and 1 cup of a low-calorie, unsweetened liquid such as almond milk or water.
  • Use one scoop of a low-sugar protein powder, which typically contains about 25 grams of protein, says Veltkamp.
  • Add as much ice as needed and blend until smooth.
  • Use the shake to replace a meal such as a dinner or lunch to help you achieve a calorie deficit.
  • Don’t Miss: What Protein Powder Can I Buy With Food Stamps

    The Science Behind Meal Replacement Shakes

    Think of a meal replacement shake as a way to incorporate nutrition into your day whenever you lack the time to plan a healthy meal and/or sit down and eat it, says obesity medicine physician Dr. Fatima Cody Stanford, MD, MPH, an educator and policy maker at Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School. Sold by the bottle or in a powder designed to be mixed with water or the milk of your choice, most meal replacement shakes provide a variety of important macronutrientsthat is, carbohydrates, protein, and fatand micronutrients, i.e., vitamins and minerals. However, all shakes aren’t created equal, Dr. Stanford saysand they cant completely replicate a healthy diet full of whole foods containing antioxidants and the plant compounds known as phytochemicals, both of which protect your cells, Jones adds.

    What Is A Protein Shake

    How Effective Are Protein Shakes For Weight Loss? | Nutritionist Explains… | Myprotein

    A protein shake is a single drink intended to deliver protein to supplement a regular diet. When I use the term, I am referring to meal replacement protein shakes, which include other nutrients and are often used for weight loss and weight maintenance programs.

    Depending on the program, protein shakes can replace one or two of the usually three daily meals. These shakes exert their effect by reducing portion size, consequently minimizing caloric intake, all the while providing excellent nutritional balance and satiety.

    Don’t Miss: Can You Buy Pedialyte On Food Stamps

    Evidence Why Meal Replacements Are Effective

    In 2018, researchers from the University of Oxford published a systematic review and meta-analysis of meal replacements for weight management. They reviewed 14 studies that compared the effect of weight loss interventions that incorporated meal replacements to those of alternative interventions.

    They concluded that meal replacements are superior to usual diet and calorie restriction.

    What Are The Disadvantages Of Weight Loss Shakes

    • A short term solution: Weight loss shakes can be a great way to help you kick some bad habits to the curb and improve your health, but its not a sustainable option. Without practicing portion control on your food, you might end up gaining back the weight you shed as soon as you stop drinking them. A healthy follow through on diet and exercise can help with that.
    • Not the be-all source of nutrition: Although they can be used as a meal replacement, nothing will ever beat fresh vegetables, grains, fruit and lean protein. Its important to know the types of vitamins and minerals your body needs in a day. Diet shakes may be able to fulfill some of your bodys basic needs, but its always best if they are combined with some real food.
    • Can lead to unhealthy diets: Whatever you do, you dont want to get so involved and obsessed with meal replacements that you start to see exercise and healthy eating as a chore. Eating in moderation also requires willpower. Hence, you might resort to keep drinking the smoothies and not get the nutrition needed from real food. Its important to be realistic and dont be too hard on yourself.

    Recommended Reading: Which Protein Powder Can You Buy With Food Stamps

    Benefits Of Drinking A Protein Shake Before Bed

    A convenient breakfast drink can double as an excellent pre-sleep drink, too. Protein shakes are best known for building muscles, but they can have extra advantages when consumed at bedtime. Since

    A convenient breakfast drink can double as an excellent pre-sleep drink, too. Protein shakes are best known for building muscles, but they can have extra advantages when consumed at bedtime.

    Since early mornings are the best time for working out, drinking a post-workout protein shake during breakfast is common amongst many health-conscious Americans. Protein compensates for energy expenditure during exercise and helps build muscles. However, severalWiley studiesVerified SourceWileyMultinational publishing company specializing in academic and instructional materials.View sourceshow protein-ingestion at bedtime can improve your muscle strength, size, and fiber intake.

    Why Is Protein Powder Good For Weight Loss

    Do Protein Shakes Promote Weight Loss

    As you probably realize, protein powders are very high in protein, which may have you wondering how it can help you drop those extra pounds. In order to lose weight, you must burn off more calories than you are consuming throughout the day, hence the importance of exercising. You want your diet to be comprised of food items that are high in nutrients but low in calories. Highly processed foods, like chips and white bread, often contain a lot of added sugars, which can cause health issues like increased risk of heart disease while also boost your calorie intake without providing any nutrients.

    Protein powders are a great snack replacement because they are often low in calories but high in other nutrients your body requires, including protein, calcium, iron and magnesium, amongst others. When purchasing a protein powder, however, you want to carefully examine the ingredients to ensure that there are no artificial ingredients or added sugars. Some companies will mix in sugar to make the protein powder taste better, but it can greatly hurt your fitness goals.

    Recommended Reading: Do You Subtract Protein From Carbs

    Meal Replacement Shakes For Men Vs Women

    Generally, men tend to have more muscle mass than women and therefore, may have higher daily protein needs, Chapmon saysone reason why some meal replacement shakes may appear to be marketed toward a specific sex.

    That said, at the end of the day, the quality of your diet comes down to the sum of its parts. If youre concerned about not getting enough macronutrients or vitamins and minerals for your lifestyle, or feel overwhelmed when it comes to choosing a quality product, guidance from a registered dietitian can be helpful, Frain says.

    Otherwise, eating a variety of colorful vegetables, beans, fruits, whole grains, light dairy, and lean proteins should provide the proper amount of vitamins, minerals, and macronutrients for most people, according to US Department of Health and Human Services.

    Are Plant Protein Shakes Good

    Most plant proteins are not considered complete proteins, which means they do not contain adequate levels of all the essential amino acids required for protein synthesis on their own. Some critical plant proteins, for instance, have low levels of isoleucine and lysine. This should not be an issue if you choose a plant protein powder that employs a variety of plant sources to offer all of the essential amino acids, but it is something to keep in mind if you are thinking about going with a single-source protein powder.

    Whey and plant protein powders are both nutritious and effective additions to any diet and exercise routine, but you will probably discover that one suits your needs better than the other.

    In general, pick plant proteins over whey if you want a long-lasting protein that will help you lose weight or if you are on a vegan or lactose-free diet. Whey protein may be more effective if you want a fast-absorbing complete protein to help you develop and repair muscle swiftly.

    Also Check: What Are Premier Protein Shakes Good For

    Establish A Weight Loss Program With Goals

    When using protein powder as part of your weight loss regimen, you should begin by creating a specific plan with goals for yourself. Determine how many calories you should be consuming each day and how many you need to burn. Then, determine a meal schedule. This plan doesnt have to demonstrate every single thing youll eat every day, but it should be more of an outline or guideline for how to eat to lose weight. You can plan to drink protein shakes in the morning as a breakfast meal replacement or integrate them throughout the day as snacks.

    Then, make a list of healthy dinner proteins that you can rotate throughout each night to give your diet variety while consuming foods packed with nutrients. Fatty fishes, like salmon, and chicken are two great sources of protein you can eat for dinner each night.

    Once youve determined how to count your calories and which foods are good to integrate into your diet, you should come up with a realistic goal for how much weight youd like to lose. You can start off small by setting a monthly weight loss goal or go big and decide how much weight youd like to lose in three, six, or nine months.

    Can I Replace A Meal With A Protein Shake

    How To Use Protein Shakes For Weight Loss

    It is safe to replace a meal with a whey protein shake, but moderation is key. Its still important to eat a range of whole foods to receive the nutrients you need, including protein .

    Whey protein powder is a supplement, so treat it as such! If youre going to replace a meal with a protein shake, try to limit it to once per day to ensure youre still getting the proper nutrition. Additionally, you can ask your nutritionist or dietician for assistance in finding the right balance for you.

    Don’t Miss: Nature Valley Protein Bars Bodybuilding

    What Is A Protein Shake Diet

    A typical protein shake diet will replace one or two meals per day with a pre-purchased shake or one you prepare yourself using a soy-based or whey protein powder and some form of liquid. Many dieters use water because it doesn’t add calories, but you can also use milk or juice.

    Let’s take a look at one popular protein diet meal plan and consider a few points that may help you decide whether or not it’s right for you.

    Bottom Line: Are Protein Shakes Good For Weight Loss

    While our experts do believe that protein shakes can help with weight loss, they also agree that it’s always best to rely on whole foods first. After all, protein shakes, despite their filling nature, may actually make you snack more.

    “Protein shakes are not food, so they may not give you the satisfaction you would get from eating,” Reisdorf says. “Also, it is easy to add a ton of extra calories via fruit or other additives to a protein shake. That won’t help with weight loss either.”

    “Smoothies for weight loss can be challenging, as there are several studies that point to the effect of chewing and satiety,” agrees NutriBullet‘s registered dietitian Sherene Chou. “Meaning, feeling satiated through the act of chewing and eating foods evidence suggesting that chewing may decrease intake and self-reported hunger.”

    While most people, Wolbers notes, “are unable to consume all that protein from whole foods,” the high levels of vitamins and minerals contained in whole foods make them a superior choice because losing weight increases your nutrient needs and “protein powders are good , but not great.”

    “Overall, I would say that using protein shakes with moderation combined with a healthy diet loaded with fruits and veggies is the best way to lose weight,” Djordjevic says.

    Read Also: What Protein Powder Can Be Bought With Food Stamps

    How To Use Meal Replacement Shakes

    If you want to incorporate meal replacement shakes into your weight loss journey, two small studies published in 2012 and 2018 suggest that replacing one to two meals a day with meal replacement beverages may increase weight loss, Jones saysbut its important to note that each of these studies were conducted on less than 200 people and only went on for 12 weeks. So while there may be short-term benefits, the long-term advantages remain to be seen.

    If youre thinking of supplementing your diet with shakes , Jones recommends sticking to half a serving. Drinking a full shake between meals may ultimately lead you to consume more calories than your body needs, which could contribute to weight gain.

    Popular Articles

    Related Articles