Can I Replace Meals With Protein Shakes To Lose Weight

Are Protein Shakes Good For You


The unsurprising answer is yes. Of course, an extra dose of protein is a great choice for a snack or meal replacement. Many athletes use protein shakes as a way to refuel after exercise. All adults need a minimum of 46-56 grams of protein each day and these shake recipes are a great way to meet that goal.

The best protein shake recipes, including the 5 that are shown below, rely on whey protein powder for that extra nutrition. Whey protein has many benefits, including all of the following:

  • Builds muscle and strength
  • Provides balance for the body systems with amino acids
  • Repairs muscles from exercise

Additionally, these healthy drinks are quick to make, portable, and you dont need any cooking skills or preparation to make them!

Q4 Are Meal Replacement Shakes The Same As A Protein Shake

No, they are not the same as protein shake, as the latter contain only protein. While MR has most of the micro and macronutrients, protein shakes are not intended to replace a meal.

Instead, they are for bodybuilders and for those willing to gain muscles. Therefore, they cannot substitute for a whole meal as meal replacement shakes do.

How To Structure Your Diet To Replace Meals With Protein Shakes

When trying to make a whole new dieting routine a hit, you need to plan it the right way.

Heres what to do for different meals when trying to replace them with protein shakes.

#1. Breakfast

Can you replace breakfast with a protein shake? Yes, you can.

It is easy to prepare and you can take it on the go. Whether you have a busy morning or a hectic schedule, the easy-peasy drink offers good nutrition on the go.

However, during the afternoon, you need to have something real.

#2. Lunch

Lunch is an odd time to replace meals. However, some prefer having protein shakes instead of a proper lunch.

Mostly, it includes lunchtime gym-goers. If your workout timing meets your lunch hours, its good to go.

Meanwhile, you need to ensure your stomach gets something good afterward.

Training drains the energy out of you. This increases the necessity for some real thing at dinner. You can even try post-workout snacks.

#3. Dinner

The heavy-calorie meal goes to your dinner plate. Therefore, most prefer to swap their dinner with a protein drink.

However, if you work out in the evenings or at night, it may not suit you. This also applies in the case of unconventional lifestyle habits.

You can think about whats best for you and what your workout timing is.

#4. Snacks

This is the best time to drink meal replacement protein shake. Most have unhealthy snacking habits. Consider having a protein shake instead.

Indeed, what you expect from one of the best workout nutrition.

Also Check: Can You Get Protein Powder With Food Stamps

Whens The Best Time To Drink A Protein Shake For Weight Loss

When it comes to using a protein powder for weight loss, its important to consider the best time to have it throughout the day, to ensure youre getting the maximum benefits. We recommend having a protein shake or smoothie roughly 30-45 minutes prior to exercise, which will help to boost energy levels and therefore allow you to burn more calories.

Consuming a protein shake or smoothie within 30 minutes post-workout will provide the body with essential amino acids that will help promote muscle growth, as well as aid in muscle repair. This will allow your body to rest and recover well, which is ideal for those that have weight loss goals and want to train frequently.

New to the smoothie and shake world? Not sure how to make delicious protein drinks to help with weight loss? Read some of our tips and tricks below, to help you create delicious protein shakes and smoothies every time!

To Cut Calories And Carbs

10 Delicious Protein Shakes for Weight Loss and Staving ...

Meal replacement shakes can also cut calories and carbohydrates from a full meal, and at a caloric range of 200-400 per shake, it can help you manage your calories and lose weight. If youre also cutting carbohydrates to lose weight, they can help with that as well, especially if you get a brand that uses stevia or monk fruit.

However, if you snack between meals, a meal replacement shake will not help cut calories or carbs. As everything that you eat adds up, snacking could put your calorie, and carb counts higher than what your body can burn at any one time.

You May Like: Can I Buy Whey Protein With Food Stamps

How Much Weight Can I Lose With Meal Replacement Shakes

You can lose 1-2 lbs per week with meal replacement shakes because they will create a caloric deficit. People do more intense restrictions in favor of fat loss. However, in the long term, it can bring you more harm than good because lowering the calories further can lead to unwanted overeating.

In other words, more restriction doesnt guarantee better results. Caloric deficit leads to putting extra stress on the body and if this stress will add up and continue over a long time it can trigger binge eating .

Then we feel guilty and shameful, so we end up adding even more restriction and more stress.

The easy way out is to focus on a small and achievable changes that can be done over time. This build up the habits and help you reduce the stress, not add more.

You may see multiple articles of people claiming that you can replace your one meal a day with some super shake. And usually, in the end, they want to sell you that shake.

And thats just the sad reality. They dont care will you get results or not. They dont care is that healthy for you or not. All they care about is the sale.

Today is so easy to get endorsed by influencers to promote any diet product claiming it works. And because people are naive, uncertain and they want to look like those influencers, they believe them.

Im not saying that meal replacements are bad. In fact, research is clear that meal replacements are proven to be a valid option for the management of overweight and obesity .

They work.

Should You Try This Diet

Making the choice to follow a liquid protein diet plan is a highly individual thing. In short, yes, you can lose weight with protein shakes. A diet that reduces caloric intake will help you to slim down regardless of whether the calories come from solid food or liquid food.

And because the protein shakes usually have fewer calories than the meals you would typically consume, you will probably see results.

In addition, when you boost your protein intake with shakes or smoothies, you help your body to maintain muscle mass. You might even gain muscle if you are also doing strength training workouts at home or at the gym. A body with more muscle will burn more calories all day long than a body that has more fat.

You May Like: Protein Shakes And Cholesterol

Best Value: Slimfast Advanced Energy Meal Replacement Shakes

4.5 out of 5 stars19,400+ Amazon customer reviews

SlimFast’s meal replacement shakes are packed with 20 grams of protein and five grams of fiber, helping you stay fuller longer. Plus, they offer 24 different essential vitamins and minerals, including vitamin D, iron, calcium, and zinc to fuel your body. Enjoy them in a variety of taste-tempting flavors like rich chocolate, vanilla, and orange cream swirl. Reviewers particularly love the chocolate flavor: The Creamy Chocolate reminds me of a milkshake. It is very filling and delicious with no aftertaste, says one Amazon customer.

Make it a meal: Save these drinks for when you can pair them with something smalllike 1/2 cup 2% cottage cheese and one cup of sliced strawberriesto turn them into a complete meal. This way, youll add about 150 extra calories, 13 grams protein, 3 grams fiber, and 2.5 grams fat.

Nutrition info for chocolate: 180 calories, 9 g fat , 7 g carbs , 180 mg sodium, 20 g protein

Why Protein And Fiber Are So Important

Meal Replacement Shakes Weight Loss

At this point, you know that its important to get a meal replacement shake with the right ingredients. There are certain ingredients that are more important than others, namely protein and fiber.

Many meal replacement shakes contain plant-based proteins, such as whey or soy protein. Dietary fiber is also a major ingredient in many of these products.

The reason for this is that both of these ingredients are very important in the management of appetite and hunger.

Fat is also an important ingredient in a meal replacement shake. As long as it contains good, healthy fats, they will work with the hormones of your body to tell you to stop eating at the right time. However, more important are protein and fiber.


There are certain reasons to seek out a meal replacement shake with high protein content. They are as follows:

  • Protein is more likely to make you feel full than other nutrients.
  • You will digest protein more slowly than you will digest carbohydrates. This means that the protein will be present in your gastrointestinal tract for a longer period of time.
  • The source of the protein often doesnt matter. Whether it is plant-based or animal-based, it will have a similar effect on your appetite.
  • If your shake contains soy-based protein, this is also a good source of fiber.


Fiber is also a very important ingredient to look for when you are finding a meal replacement shake. The following are reasons why:

Don’t Miss: Are Protein Shakes Covered By Ebt

Weight Loss With Meal Replacement Shakes: Is It Sustainable

Even though meal replacement shakes have shown themselves to be effective in weight loss, it also appears that the results are not necessarily sustainable.

In August 2013, Diabetes Spectrum reported that in order for people drinking these shakes to sustain the weight loss over the long term, they need to continue drinking them instead of eating meals.

In addition, many people end up gaining the weight back because they have a tendency to underestimate how many calories they are taking in per day that include the meal replacement shakes.

There are a few other reasons why the weight loss tends to be temporary when people rely on meal replacement shakes. Calorie restriction causes alterations to your metabolism and hormones, which makes it difficult for any changes to last.

When you engage in calorie restriction, levels of the hormone ghrelin rise, while those of the hormone leptin decrease. Ghrelin tells you that it is time to eat, while leptin tells you that youre full, so this means that youre hungry all the time.

Adaptive thermogenesis is another factor. When you restrict calories, your body also decreases the number of calories you burn during activity.

Cul Es El Mejor Batido Sustitutivo De Una Comida Para Bajar De Peso

Reemplazo de comidas más vendido

  • # 1. HealthKart SlimShake sin azúcares añadidos – 1 kg de chocolate. 4.5 371 reseñas. 1,125 2,250 50% de descuento. 1,091 INR para los miembros de HK.
  • # 2. Batido de reemplazo de mesa Incredio – 1 kg de mango. 4.3 de 217 valoraciones. 1,124 2,250 50% de descuento.
  • # 3. Doctor’s Choice Lean Pro – 0.5 kg de batido de mango. 4.1 según 7 valoraciones. 1,599 2,399 33% de descuento.

Also Check: Do Special K Protein Bars Make You Gain Weight

Soylent Meal Replacement Shakes

4.4 out of 5 stars10,500+ Amazon customer reviews

Soylent’s vegan-friendly meal replacement shakes are 400 calories, which makes them a convenient choice for a full-on meal when you don’t have time to pick up breakfast. One shake has 20 grams of protein and three grams of fiber,plus hefty doses of vitamin D, iron, magnesium, and other nutrients.Soylent is pretty good! I love chai so I was excited to try this flavor. You can definitely taste the chai and it doesnt taste too much like a protein drink. I am excited to try the other flavors and I love that it keeps me full for several hours, an Amazon reviewer writes.

Nutrition info for chai: 400 calories, 24 g fat , 38 g carbs , 300 mg sodium, 20 g protein

What Are Protein Shakes

When to drink protein shakes for weight loss

Protein shakes used to be something that only professional bodybuilders took, but now more and more people are considering the value of these shakes in their daily exercise routines.

Protein is important as it keeps us feeling full and it can help with muscle repair.

A protein shake can be as simple as mixing a certain amount of protein powder with water or other liquids. However, more and more shakes on the market may taste better, but they may also contain more sugar, calories, or artificial ingredients.

All you need is protein from this shake you can take it before or after exercise and it will boost your muscle growth, make it easier for you to recover, etc.

Most of the shakes that you can buy or make contain whey protein or casein protein. They both serve a specific purpose.

With whey, you will absorb it quickly and you should take it immediately after a workout to help with muscle repair, especially if you exercise several times a day.

However, casein is absorbed slowly. So, you can take it before sleep to repair your muscles overnight. Of course, you can mix both of these proteins together as well.

On the market, you can buy whey in many forms its the most commonly used protein. In the form of concentrate, youll be able to find it pretty inexpensively, but it contains the most protein in isolated form.

Since neither whey nor casein is vegan, you can choose to take protein from soy, brown rice, pea protein, or other plants.

Recommended Reading: Can Lack Of Protein Cause Headaches

Protein For Weight Loss

A protein shake may help curb hunger, making a low-calorie diet easier to follow. A study published in the journal Obesity in 2007 showed that a high daily protein intake can help increase your metabolism slightly and decrease your appetite. When dieting, an intake of 30 percent of daily calories from protein seemed to diminish the effects of ghrelin, a hormone that stimulates appetite.

Protein shakes do help contribute to a high daily protein intake, but not any more than protein obtained from whole foods. For example, a 3.5-ounce serving of skinless, light-meat chicken or flank steak provides 25 or 27 grams of protein, respectively, along with additional nutrients.

If you rely on supplements for most of your meals, you miss the valuable components of whole foods, such as phytonutrients, fiber and healthy fats. Protein supplements are best used as an occasional meal replacement when time or logistics doesn’t permit whole food. For example, drinking a protein shake may be convenient if it helps prevent a fast food run or candy bar snack.

Do Meal Replacement Shakes Work

If youre looking to lose weight, then a Diet Meal Replacement Shake is a simple and easy weight loss shake that will help you to shed those unwanted pounds. How? Well, to achieve weight loss you need to be in a calorie deficit, in a nutshell that means consuming less calories vs the amount of calories you burn. Our Diet Meal Replacement is a tiny 250 calories, whilst still providing a wealth of vitamins, minerals and most importantly flavour.

Sounds good so far, but we know what youre thinking With so few calories Ill be hungry straight after. This is where the magic of the TPW Geniuses comes into play. Theyve designed an optimal protein blend that brings together the perfect balance of slow and fast release proteins. This means it combines naturally with the fibre already held within our Diet Meal Replacement shakes to help you feel satiated and full

Don’t Miss: Does Ebt Cover Slim Fast

Pros Of Meal Replacement Shakes

Full of nutrients. A meal replacement shake is one way to make sure you have a healthy option if you know you wont have time to stop and eat. It might be easy to stop by a fast-food restaurant, where many options arent healthy. Plus, youll probably spend more on a burger than you would on a meal replacement shake.

Low calories. A meal replacement shake is a good addition to your diet if youre watching your weight or trying to lose weight. One downfall when losing weight is feeling hungry, and meal replacement shakes can help you overcome that obstacle.

Added fiber. In addition to protein that helps you feel full, meal replacement shakes are often high in fiber. This helps healthy digestion, so you dont get bloated or have constipation.

Proven weight loss. Research has found that meal replacement shakes can help with weight loss. One study tracked two groups of people as they tried to lose weight over the course of 3 months. At the end of the study, the group that did not use meal replacement shakes lost only 1.5% of their initial body weight. The group that used replacement shakes lost 7.8%.


Q9 Are Protein Powders/shakes Good For Meal Replacement

Two Protein Shakes Per Day Weight Loss Challenge Meal Replacement Shakes!

Protein powder contains proteins and no other elements of nutritional value. On the other hand, in meal replacement shakes, protein, fiber, fat, and all other nutrients are added. Apparently, they have different goals to achieve. So, it would be wise not to substitute one for the other.

Moreover, many meal replacements are so high in protein that they can easily be considered a protein shake. Some of these include fats, fiber, and carbohydrates, and they conform to the concept of meal replacement.

Don’t Miss: Premier Protein Sugar Free Protein Powder

Why Do I Think This Diet Might Be Your Favorite

At the end of the day this diet isnt complicated.

Technically, youre supposed to be eating a low-calorie supper so you could make that complicated if you really wanted to, but it doesnt need to be that way.

I lost weight without counting any calories.

And things that are simple are easier to do. Thats just a fact.

Some diets these days have so many steps, ingredients, and details to remember that, lets face it, its realistically too much to take on and stick with for the average person who already has a busy, chaotic life.

When something is easy youre more likely to stick with it and get the results youre looking for.

Popular Articles

Related Articles