Are Atkins Protein Shakes Healthy

Real Ketones Keto Meal

Why do I drink Atkins Protein Shakes?
  • Has only 160 calories

Keto Meal is a ketogenic super meal which combines the strength and energy of proteins and ketones in one tasty, easy-to-mix powder.

The primary disadvantage of the Kegenix Keto Meal is that it delivers only 160 calories of energy per serving. Plus, the percentage of fat calories is lower than in other products.

Note: Kegenix recently rebranded itself and is now called Real Ketones.

If you want to try Kegenix, Id recommend doubling the serving size so that you get at least 320 calories. However, doing so will also add 16 grams of carbs, which is a lot considering the 50-carb calorie limit of some keto dieters.

It comes in two flavors , and contains the necessary electrolytes, micronutrients , and macronutrients that every good keto meal replacement drink should have.

Except for guar gum, Kegenix doesnt have any potentially gut-irritating ingredients and contains no added sugars or artificial sweeteners.

Recommended Reading: How Does Protein Help The Body Lose Weight

Premier Protein 30g Protein Shake


  • Soy free. This shake derives most of its protein from a milk protein blend, rather than from soy. Perfect for those who are sensitive to soy or are trying to limit their intake.
  • 30g of protein. Premier Proteins shakes have one of the highest amounts of protein per serving available. The 30g tally almost doubles some of its most likely competitors.
  • 160 calories. For those hoping to achieve their weight loss goals, this product may be hard to pass on. Most of the 160 calories in the shake come from protein, not sugar or fat, as those two respectively only make up 1g and 3g of the formula.


  • Milk-based. While this product really goes the mile in terms of packing in protein, it may not be the solution for people who are sensitive to dairy or lactose intolerant, or are simply trying to avoid dairy.
  • Not thick unless chilled. This drink is best served when chilled overnight. If not stored at a cold enough temperature, the drink will be less shake and more liquid, making it feel less filling.

Premier Protein makes a protein shake that is loaded with 30g of protein in only an 11.5 ounce bottle. Despite all that protein, it only contains 160 calories and one gram of sugar, making it ideal as a weight-loss tool.

Too Many Protein Shakes Could Lead To Acidosis

Our bodies have a solid homeostatic spot that they like to live on the pH scale. Human bodies like to remain at 7.35 to 7.45 pH, with varying levels present in different systems. Slight fluctuations overall can cause serious harm, illnesses, and death .

Your kidneys regulate many of the body’s pH-balanced systems. If you choose to overconsume protein and overwork your kidneys, they may have trouble regulating the systems they are responsible for. Though uncommon, acidosis can happen as a result of too much protein, as a study in the Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition revealed. Symptoms include fatigue, weakness, irritability, difficulty losing weight, and more .

If you want to consume a boatload of protein without forcing your body into this condition, the experts at BioTech USA recommend consuming a balanced diet. Specifically, they recommend eating a large volume of vegetables in conjunction with the protein to prevent this from happening.

You May Like: G Plan Fat Protein Efficient Diet

Sugar And Sweeteners Includes Sucralose

Next up, sugar. The ingredient you definitely dont want in any type of healthy lifestyle shake. First the good news Atkins Shakes only contain 1g of sugar per serving. This is obviously great for low-carb and low/no sugar diets.

The problem is that instead, they use the artificial sweetener, Sucralose, to sweeten the shake. Studies show that not only might artificial sweeteners be bad for our health in the long-run, but they can also contribute to weight gain!

This is because these fake sugars mess with your bodys ability to count calories, and as a result you may end up eating more food and therefore more calories than you would have otherwise.

In addition, artificial sweeteners dont give the brain the same reward sensation that eating regular sugar does. And our bodies simply arent as satisfied, so we just may end up eating something else that actually has real sugar in it later. Well tell ourselves its okay, because we skimped on real sugar earlier in the day!

In this way, artificial sugars can actually cause us to eat an unhealthy diet while thinking we are eating healthy!

Muscle Milk Protein Smoothie

Atkins Mocha Latte Shake 4 pk

Don’t be fooled by our favorite word “smoothie.” Although protein powders and smoothies go together rather nicely, we’re only talking about the homemade versions which use real yogurt. Muscle Milk claims to use Greek yogurt, but they also note that the drink is heat-treated after culturing, which kills off any live cultures that may have had probiotic benefits.

Don’t Miss: Nature Valley Protein Bars Bodybuilding

Bolthouse Farms Protein Plus

They might be naturally sweetened, but that doesn’t justify gulping down nearly 50 grams of sugar in a bottle. It’ll give you a solid dose of protein along with vitamins and minerals, but you’ll most likely start to feel hungry soon after guzzling down the nearly 400-calorie bottlewhich isn’t great news if you’re on a calorie-restricted diet.

Taste Is Good And Convenient

Ok, not an actual item, but kind of actually is. Premier Protein shakes are a keto-friendly source that tastes pretty good relative to many other whey protein shakes and protein powders Ive tried. The ready to drink containers are also a convenient option for anyone on the go.

However, youre more than welcome to use any other source or keto-friendly protein shake if Premier shakes dont suit your preferences. Any whey protein, protein powder, or protein shake is perfectly acceptable just stick to low carb protein sources.

Another great brand in the ready to drink category is Muscle Milk, another recommendation of mine in the flavor department. Give my article down below a read to determine which ones are low carb and which ones are high in carbohydrates and should be avoided.

Also Check: Protein Treatments For Natural Black Hair

Nature’s Best Isopure Cocotein

Although it boasts one of the shortest ingredient lists out of every protein drink on the marketonly including water, Isopure’s whey protein isolate, coconut water concentrate, natural flavor, and phosphoric acidwe had to tick this drink off because of the addition of an artificial sweetener, sucralose. Although recent science indicate they’re not carcinogenic, as feared, artificial sweeteners have been shown to either increase or show no effect on your appetite and can harm your gut health due to their indigestibility.

Protein Source Contains Soy


The problem in the Atkins shakes comes from the source of the protein its a blend containing soy protein isolate.

Our problem with soy protein stems from the fact that it contains phytoestrogens which are basically estrogen mimickers in your body. Obviously, having extra estrogen in your body could cause some problems for both males and females, including messing with your hormones.

The other problem is that 90 percent of the soy used today is genetically modified ! Genetically modified foods come with their own host of potential health problems. This is mainly because they destroy the good bacteria in the gut, negatively effecting immune and digestive health.

Organic soy is the only safe bet to be non-GMO, since there are no harsh chemicals, fertilizers or pesticides used while growing. The problem is that most of the soy used in products today is not organic! And this is the case with the Atkins shake since the label does not say organic.

Since there is still no much unknown about the potential negative health effects of consuming soy on a regular basis, we believe its best to avoid this protein, especially since there are so many other nutritious options.

Recommended Reading: Can Collagen Supplements Cause Headaches

Owyn Vegan Protein Shake Cookies And Cream

We’re big advocates for using plant protein powders. Unlike whey powders, plant protein won’t lead to bloat, are less likely to include nasty artificial sweeteners, and have been found to be just as effective in building muscle and strength, according to a Nutrition Journal study.

“OWYN are 100% plant-based, with no artificial sweeteners, and contain a good source of protein and fiber. This winning combo helps keep blood sugars stabilized and hunger at bay. They are also a good source of iron and plant omega-3s!” says Moskovitz.

Are Atkins Shakes Keto Friendly

This site is reader-supported and we earn commissions if you purchase products from retailers after clicking on a link from our site. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

The Atkins diet is another popular low-carb diet like keto that also promotes healthy eating and weight loss.

Youve probably heard about Atkins products, and their shakes are considered the most low-carb. If used correctly, these shakes are a good option for weight loss.

But are Atkins Shakes keto-friendly?

We discuss the ingredients and nutritional information in Atkins Shakes and whether they make a good meal replacement.

Find out if these shakes are good for weight loss and whether they are suitable for the keto diet.

Recommended Reading: Headache From Lack Of Protein

Your Muscles May Repair Faster

A complete protein is made up of all 20 amino acids. Amino acids can be split up into two categories: essential and nonessential . The nine essential amino acids cannot be made by your body and thus need to be consumed to create a complete protein structure. When you eat protein, it is broken down by its amino acids. Each specific compound goes forth and performs its unique job in the body. Fun fact: Every single cell in your body contains some form of protein .

When you lift weights or work out, you are essentially damaging your muscle fibers. As a response to the imposed demands, your muscle fibers can grow back stronger. This is what leads to muscular hypertrophy, per Healthline. If you provide your body with plenty of protein, your muscles will have most of the tools that they need to repair optimally .

However, if you drink only protein shakes, your body will likely miss out on micronutrients. Many micronutrients are most available in colorful, nourishing, whole foods. By bypassing these health-boosting nutrients, you’d ultimately be doing your body a disservice by not providing all of the elements needed for a full recovery .

Should You Drink Protein Shakes Every Day

12 Atkins Mocha Latte Protein Rich Shake for $12.04 Shipped

The Bottom Line However, research suggests it doesn’t matter whether you drink a protein shake before or after your workout. Interestingly, your total daily protein intake is what matters most. While protein shakes around workouts and between meals are helpful, make sure you’re getting enough throughout the day.

You May Like: Protein Powder High Cholesterol

Should I Choose Atkins Low Carb Products

If youre in the market for a new brand of protein bar or low carb supplement, theres a lot to consider to ensure that you make the right choice to suit your lifestyle. It pays to not only research into what flavours are available, but also the nutritional breakdown of each product so that you can compare the nutritional value of individual Atkins bars and products. Looking at the suggested serving quantity, the amount of protein and carbs, and also other ingredients that may be included such as soy, gluten or nuts, may help you to decide whether Atkins is the brand for you.

Atkins is primarily a weight loss brand and targets those who are following low carb diets, or are looking for snack alternatives that contain less sugar than regular nut or chocolate bars. While not necessarily fitness driven, Atkins products do contain higher amounts of protein so they may also be suitable for active lifestyles, to boost your energy and help with recovery. However if youre looking to revamp your diet, its best to consult your doctor before diving into any new eating regime.

Orgain Organic Nutritional Shake


  • Free of artificial colors and flavors. Orgain strives to offer as natural of a protein shake as possible, forgoing any artificial flavors or colorings. Many competitors rely on artificial colors and flavors to create a sweeter and more appealing looking drink.
  • Organic protein. The protein in every one of these shakes is certified organic, meaning the USDA has declared that it was cultivated in an approved manner. Perfect for those shopping for truly certified organic protein products.
  • Money-back guarantee. Though most users will probably be satisfied with this shake, the manufacturers are so confident in this drink that they have a full money-back guarantee if not satisfied. Unlikely as it is that a customer will act on this offer, it is relieving to see the faith the producers have in their product.


  • Whey protein. Some of the protein contained in this shake is derived from whey. Whey is a common source of protein but can cause digestion issues for some people.
  • Higher sugar than powder version. Though not terribly high in sugar for a protein drink, it has a higher sugar content than the powdered offering from Orgain. While it makes the drink taste better, people who are looking for the lowest sugar content might find other options that fit their needs better.

Read Also: How Much Gold Standard Whey Protein Should I Take

Carbohydrates Low Net Carbs

Obviously, since this is an Atkins shake which is part of the Atkins low-carb diet, it offers low-carbs at 7g per serving. The label also tells you the amount of net carbs that you receive in each shake. You get net carbs by subtracting the fiber from the total amount of carbs to get 2g of Atkins net carbs.

Obviously, for anyone following a low-carb diet, this is a great shake to help you stick to that plan, even though there are some concerns in the sugar department

Ranking The Best Protein Shakes Of 2021

Can Atkins shakes be used as a meal replacement

Protein shakes are flavored blends of protein supplements that are easy to mix up into a shake or smoothie when youre on the go.

The right protein shake can help you lose fat, maintain muscle mass, get toned, recover from tough workouts, and stamp out hunger pangs.

However, theres a lot of variability in quality when it comes to protein shakes. Our research team has picked out the ten best protein shakes to help you stay lean, fit, and healthy.


If you like your shakes clean and green, and if you like your body lean, then Performance Lab® SPORT Protein hits the spot. Its 100% organic and vegan-friendly. With no fillers, soy, or synthetics. No additives, and no animal content.

Instead its made from whole brown rice protein. Naturally sweetened with yacon root, monk fruit and stevia. And naturally flavored with cocoa, vanilla, and cinnamon.

This is a premium muscle fuel that packs a powerful protein punch. It will suit every diet and lifestyle, and mixes quickly and easily in a shaker bottle.

If you are going to get any protein shake on the market, and lactose isnt an issue, this is Bodynutritions #1 choice.

You May Like: Fat And Protein Efficient Metabolism Diet

Avant Edge Carb Control

Avant Edge Carb Control is the lowest carb protein shake out there. It uses pea and soy protein, so its great for people who have to avoid dairy-derived protein.

The carb avoidance comes at the cost of low fiber content as well, so it may not be as filling as some other protein shakes that also have high dietary fiber content.

It has the expected vitamin and mineral ingredients, and beyond this, Its nothing fancy, but if you want to keep your carb count as low as possible, its a very good choice.

Are Atkins Shakes Good For Keto


Additionally, on the keto diet, you want to keep your body in ketosis by extremely limiting your carb intake. On the other hand, the Atkins diet has you gradually increase your carb intake, which will eventually kick your body out of ketosis.

Similarly, how many carbs are in a Atkins shake? The Atkins shakes weigh in with 20 grams of high-quality protein, 2 to 4 grams of fiber, only 1 to 2 grams of net carbs and nary a drop of high-fructose corn syrup or other added sugars or any trans fatty acidsand all with 170 calories.

Subsequently, question is, can you drink protein shakes on keto diet?

While you can likely meet your protein needs through your diet, protein powders offer a convenient and easy way to increase your intake. Many people following low-carb or ketogenic diets turn to protein powders to supplement their diet.

What is the best keto shake?

Here are the 10 best keto smoothie recipes that are low in carbs and high in fat.

  • Triple berry avocado breakfast smoothie.
  • Chocolate peanut butter smoothie.
  • Dont Miss: How Much Protein In Almond Milk

    Read Also: Cholesterol In Protein Powder Good Or Bad

    You Could Have Diarrhea

    Diarrhea is an unpleasant but common side effect of eating too much protein or something else that doesn’t totally agree with your system. Like flatulence, the occasional bout of diarrhea is typical following the consumption of protein with excess lactose or sugar alcohols .

    According to Medical News Today, diarrhea can also be a sign of overconsumption of protein. Many athletes or people with physically demanding jobs may require more than the recommended daily amount of protein, but some people’s bodies don’t process a ton of protein well at all. Generally speaking, the actual protein molecules won’t cause diarrhea unless consumed in excess over the long term. However, excess protein consumption has been linked to diseases that reach far beyond the discomfort and nuisance of GI problems, though. With this in mind, we can assure you that only drinking protein shakes is a bad idea.

    Popular Articles

    Related Articles